This is Your Hometown
by Rich Wisniewski
My former professor, sportswriter Phil Anastasia repeatedly told Matt Shanley, Cori Egan, John Russo and myself that a rule in sports journalism is that you can’t be a fan when it comes to writing a game story. You can’t have any opinion in a straight forward sports story. That’s usually reserved for columnist, or radio talk show hosts.
But he also told us that it is ok to be human, and have feelings. Basically it is ok to personalize some stories that hit a little closer to home.
Which is why, the recent story about Phillies fan Matthew Clemmens and his classless acts have really taken a toll on me. And while I’m not defending his act by no account, it isn’t that story that has gotten to me. It’s the reaction from the country to once again denounce the “Philadelphia sports fan”.
Ok let’s get it out of the way: we booed Santa Claus and threw snowballs at him (in 1968 no less). We cheered Michael Irvin’s injury and we threw car batteries at J.D. Drew. Then there’s this these tidbits: Our only real winner is Rocky and he’s not even real. We’re frontrunners, and we boo our great players like Eric Lindros, Charles Barkley, Ron Jaworski and most recently Donovan McNabb.
But what you don’t understand or even see is that we’re real. As cliché as it sounds, Philly is blue-collar, based on hard work, toughness, and passion. To the rest of the country we could be seen as arrogant, disgusting and rude…but that’s just you. What you don’t see is a city that is based on longshoreman, construction workers and downright union men and women. Even the people who have made it to the top, did it by a never say die attitude and a blue collar mindset such as working for what you want and not sitting back and waiting for it. The face of Philadelphia is not a business suit with a 100 dollar haircut, or a tanned pretty boy holding a surf board. The face of Philly is jeans, work boots, a tee-shirt and a baseball hat. And were fine with it.
Why did we boo McNabb, Schmidt, Lindros or Barkly? Well I can’t answer for everyone, bBut here’s a reason: Maybe they weren’t doing what they were supposed to do. They weren’t doing their job at one point. All four are good players, and we know that, but if you don’t play well on a particular day, you will hear it. It isn’t always about winning and losing. It can be about how you play the game. Do you play it with a passion? Do you play every game like its your last? Do you hustle? Its questions like these that were answered with a yes by players such as Larry Bowa, Pete Rose, Rod Brind A’mour, Allen Iverson, Brian Dawkins, Bobby Clark. Even T.O. found Philadelphia to be welcoming because of how he played the game.
We boo more then other cities because we watch every pitch, snap, shot, or lay-up. We don’t use games as a social gathering to discuss business plans, or trade pictures of kids. We don’t check out emails on Blackberry’s or spend time admiring the scenery. We watch. We study. We learn. A game to a Philly fan is not just a game, it’s a situation. It’s a time to set everything else aside, school, work, and family. It’s literally game time.
So while the horrendous acts from Matthew Clemmens are not defendable, people should know that that isn’t the whole city. So if your going to hate us, fine. But when you want to find a city that knows its sports teams all the time, and not just when they’re winning, now you know where to look.